Maya Angelou is credited for saying, "When people show you who they are, believe them the first time." I believe the same is true for certain traits in a basketball team. For example: the Spurs had a tendency to give up leads after great starts during the 2025-26 run, and despite their growth in other areas, that same weakness came back to bite them in the Finals.
This season's canary in the coal mine is what's happening to Stephon Castle and De'Aaron Fox, so it'd be in the Spurs' best interest to heed the warning now rather than ignore it. Cast'e production is down across the board, and Fox is averaging his fewest points since his rookie season. Both are paying for the new structure.
This is another reason the three-guard lineup deserves another look. On its own, the unit is doing great. The numbers overall are pretty awesome, mostly because of how strong the defense is. But the game isn't only played by one group, and there's been a ripple effect.
Dylan Harper’s starting role is changing the Spurs’ offense
Harper is playing awesome basketball this season. His 18.4 points per game are the second-highest on the team. He's just not hitting very many threes and neither is anyone else outside of Julian Champagnie and Harrison Barnes.
Castle's overall production drop is the clearest example. His field goal percentage is down, his free throws are down, his assist numbers are down, his points per game are down. While it's not surprising to see his assist average take a hit with another ball handler starting alongside him, the rest isn't encouraging.
Again, the lineup has thrived, mostly because of the defense, but that doesn't mean everyone in it has played their best. There's always a chance that those guys will just play better with more reps, but we also have to consider that the new structure is detrimental to their offensive games.
The Spurs’ lineup needs Dylan Harper on the bench
San Antonio's offensive rating is only 0.6 percentage points worse than last year's, ranking fourth in both seasons. But the attack doesn't feel as layered as it once was. Wemby and Harper are better individually, and Fox has mostly been fine, but other than that, it's a coin flip on where the rest of the production is coming from.
It rotates between guys, whereas before, opponents would consistently feel everyone's impact. The Silver and Black would come at you in waves, flexing their depth with separate groups led by a different pair of guards.
Sending Harper back to the bench puts the ball back in Castle's hands, and lets him play the kind of bully ball that helped him get to the line five-plus times a night, and average the sixth-most assists per game for the season.
Swipa gets more chances to put his stamp on the game, and up his contributions. Fox is averaging 13.1 points, his lowest since he entered the league, while shooting 48% from the field. Give him the ball more, and we would see the 2x All-Star score more.
Harper's minutes are up (as they should be), so there will still be overlap with the other guards. However, for the stretches they do share the floor, Mitch Johnson should play Champagnie. He's a better contested three-point shooter than Vassell is this season.
The Spurs' most-used starting five last season (Fox, Vassell, Champagnie, Wembanyama, and Castle) had a plus-17.6 net rating across 284 minutes. I know this season's opening unit has been great, but that's pretty damn good too. When Wembanyama gets his first quarter rest, he should be watching the Dylan Harper show, not sitting next to him.
With Harper sidelined for the next 2-3 weeks, we'll get a chance to see just how much Harper's shine was impacting Castle and Fox. If they both start producing at a high level, the Spurs will have evidence that their guard-heavy lineup is creating a push/pull dynamic with the rest of their stars—one that could bite them later when the stakes are highest.
